Disconnection Time Requirements?

Talk Electrician Forum

Help Support Talk Electrician Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

ProMbrooke

Active member
Joined
Nov 23, 2019
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
Why do circuits 32 amps and under require a 0.4 second disconnection time at 230 volts, but circuits over 32 amps are legally allowed 5 seconds? 115 volts for 5 seconds is enough to cause injury to the body.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why do circuits 32 amps and under require a 0.4 second disconnection time at 230 volts, but circuits over 32 amps are legally allowed 5 seconds? 115 volts for 5 seconds is enough to cause injury to the body.


What is the "legal" document you refer to??

because at first I though you were discussing the non-statutory guidance of BS7671.....

But maybe not if you are talking about Legal allowances?

:coffee

 
What is the "legal" document you refer to??

because at first I though you were discussing the non-statutory guidance of BS7671.....

But maybe not if you are talking about Legal allowances?

:coffee




BS7671, Table 41.1. :)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
It looks perfectly logical to me. Equipment users are much more likely to come into contact with fault current from a sub-32amp circuit than from a higher current one.

 
It looks perfectly logical to me. Equipment users are much more likely to come into contact with fault current from a sub-32amp circuit than from a higher current one.




Yes, but 115 volts for 5 seconds violates the IEC's body graph.

 
OP, You make the mistake of assuming the 5seconds has much to do with the limits of human withstand, it does not, the 0.4 seond disconnection time is based on protecting persons, it used to apply to just cirucits suppling socket outlets, but over the years, as gradually been increased in scope. In line with wat Geoff said, we are worried about equipment the user might be grasping hold off and unable to let go of if they get a shock, AC is slightly better than DC, but it doesn't follow that you'll be able to throw the metal cased drill away if it comes live! (DC makes your muscles contract and not let go, AC you are there twitching with no control....) The 5second disconnection time is somewat arbitrary, legend has it that a wiring regs commitee member did a fag packet caluclation of what could be reasonably achieved in an installation he had knowledge of, and 5 seconds is what it ended up being. You arn't likely to remain in contact with fixed equipment that has given you a shock, you quickly move your hand away from the live light fitting, or worst case fall off your steps, etc

Touch voltage is not always going to be 50% of supply voltage either, if its twin and earth with a reduced CPC , it'll be quite a bit higher, if the cirucit is in MICC, however, it'll be lower

 
Top